Free HDB valuations and condo shortlists WhatsApp +65 9182 3072 Call Contact

Personal Accident vs Disability Income Insurance

Personal accident pays a lump sum after an accident. Disability income pays up to 80% of salary each month after illness or injury. They are not the same cover.

See numbers for
Bars stepping down, suggesting income that continues and then reduces
A lump sum and a monthly benefit answer different absences from work.
Months of salary in the personal accident lump sumEnter salary and coverPersonal accident pays for an accident. Disability income pays a monthly amount for illness or accident, and MoneySense says that amount is up to 80% of average monthly salary.
Your pay, and the two quotes

MoneySense, updated 28 September 2026: disability income pays a fixed monthly amount if you cannot work because of illness or accident, up to 80% of average monthly salary, after a deferred period, and it stops or reduces when you can work again. The definition of disability is the insurer's. A personal accident plan is a different contract: it follows an accident schedule and does not replace income lost to illness. Total and permanent disability on a life policy is a lump sum under that policy's definition, not this monthly benefit. We do not price either product.

Send me quotes for these figures

How we calculate

Months of salary equal the lump sum divided by salary. The 80% line is 0.8 times salary. A monthly benefit above that line is flagged. The full-term figure is the monthly benefit times 12 times the years you typed.

Inputs

  • Monthly salary
  • Personal accident lump sum
  • Disability income per month
  • Deferred period and benefit years

Assumptions

  • 80% is MoneySense's ceiling, not the benefit you will be offered
  • The lump sum is accident-only
  • Recovery can stop the monthly benefit before the term you typed

Constants and where they come from

ConstantValue usedSource
80% ceilingUp to 80% of average monthly salarymoneysense.gov.sg
On this page
  1. Calculator
  2. The short answer
  3. Pages in this cluster
  4. Three products that sound like income
  5. How to read the monthly quote
  6. What we are not pricing
  7. Listicles

Key takeaways

  • Disability income pays a monthly benefit, up to 80% of average monthly salary.
  • Payment starts after a deferred period and can stop when you return to work.
  • Personal accident follows an accident. Illness is outside that contract.
  • TPD on a life policy is a lump sum, not a salary replacement.

The numbers

Disability income
Up to 80% of average monthly salary
How long it can pay
Often 5 or 10 years, or to age 60 or 65
When it starts
After the deferred period, if you are still disabled
When it stops
When you can work again, in proportion to recovery
Personal accident
Accident schedule. Not an illness benefit.

The short answer

If the risk is an accident that kills or maims, a personal accident plan pays according to its schedule. If the risk is being unable to work, whether from that accident or from an illness, disability income insurance pays a monthly amount after a waiting period. MoneySense, updated 28 September 2026, says that monthly amount is up to 80% of your average monthly salary, that it may run for 5 or 10 years or to age 60 or 65, and that it stops or reduces when you can work again.

The calculator divides a lump sum by your salary so you can see how many months it stands in for, and it sets a monthly quote against that 80% line. It does not invent a premium.

Pages in this cluster

This guide is the hub. Each question below has its own page:

Three products that sound like income

You are worried about The product MoneySense points to What it pays
Lost salary because you cannot work Disability income A monthly amount, up to 80% of average salary, after a deferred period
A day in hospital Hospital cash A fixed sum per day, which may not match the bill
A major illness such as cancer Critical illness A lump sum on diagnosis
Severe disability and long-term care CareShield Life or ElderShield A monthly care benefit, not a salary
Death or total and permanent disability Term or whole life A lump sum for the family, or for you if the TPD definition is met

A personal accident plan sits in the accident column of that table. It is not on MoneySense’s health-insurance list as a substitute for any of the five. People buy it because the sum assured looks large next to a small premium. The right test is the months of salary in the lump sum, and whether the injury you are imagining is even on the schedule. A slipped disc from years at a desk is not an accident. A fracture from a fall may be, at a percentage of the sum assured rather than the whole of it. We do not print a generic percentage table, because each policy’s schedule is its own.

How to read the monthly quote

Type your average monthly salary and the benefit on the quote. Eighty percent of the salary is the ceiling MoneySense describes. A quote above it is a reason to ask the insurer what they will actually issue, not a reason to celebrate. A quote well below it is the gap you still carry, on top of the deferred period, which is a run of months with no benefit while you are already off work. Emergency savings have to cover that wait. The policy will not.

The term you type, 5 years or to 65 or whatever the quote says, is a maximum. Recovery reduces or ends the payment, sometimes in proportion to the work you return to. Ask which definition of disability the premium is based on. MoneySense says the premium depends on that definition, and that definitions differ. “Own occupation” and “any occupation” are not the same claim, and we will not pretend one insurer’s wording is the market’s.

The Integrated Shield calculator is about the hospital bill. This page is about the pay that stops while you are out. CareShield Life is about severe disability later. Holding all three is coherent. Treating one of them as all three is how the gap opens.

What we are not pricing

There is no reliable public tariff for personal accident or disability income that we can put in a table without pretending a campaign price is the market. The calculator stays on the arithmetic of your salary and your quote. If you want the lump-sum death and critical illness side sized to the MAS multiples, use the 9 times and 4 times calculator.

Listicles

Numbered checks for this cover. They do not rank insurers.

Page What it is
10 Questions to Ask About Personal Accident Insurance A list, not a premium table
10 Personal Accident Insurance Mistakes A list, not a premium table
10 Questions to Ask About Disability Income Insurance A list, not a premium table
10 Signs Your Income Is Not Insured A list, not a premium table

What you need before a quote

  • Average monthly salary
  • The personal accident lump sum on the schedule
  • The disability income benefit per month, the wait, and how many years it can run

Other ways to compare in Singapore

  • compareFIRST, the life-insurance shelf MoneySense points to. Direct Purchase plans there are commission-free up to the published cap.
  • The insurer's own site, if you already know the product and want its illustration.
  • A licensed insurance broker you choose. We do not name one and we do not publish a phone number for one.
  • A bank that distributes the policy, if that is where you bank. Ask them what they are paid. We do not list a rate.
  • The calculators on this site, which show a result before you send a form.

Questions on this topic

Does a personal accident plan pay if I have a stroke or cancer?

Not as an accident benefit. Those are illnesses. Critical illness cover and disability income are the contracts that deal with illness. A personal accident schedule pays for accidental death and for injuries listed on that schedule.

Is 80% the benefit I will be offered?

It is MoneySense's description of the ceiling: these policies pay up to 80% of average monthly salary, not the whole salary. The quote in front of you can be lower. If a quote is higher than 80% of the salary you type, the calculator flags it. Insurers also define disability differently, and the premium depends on that definition.

How is this different from total and permanent disability on my life plan?

TPD on a term or whole life policy is usually a lump sum under a strict definition, often that you cannot do any occupation, or that you cannot perform a set of daily activities. Disability income is a monthly amount tied to work and to a deferred period. One does not fill in for the other. The [term and critical illness guide](/term-life-critical-illness-singapore/) sizes the lump sum. This page sizes the month of pay.

What about hospital cash?

Hospital cash pays a fixed amount for each day you are warded. MoneySense says that amount may be more or less than the bill, and there may be a waiting period and a cap on days. It is not disability income, and it is not the Integrated Shield plan that pays the hospital.

Does CareShield Life replace my salary?

No. CareShield Life and its supplements pay when you cannot do enough activities of daily living. That is severe disability and long-term care. Disability income is about being unable to work, which can happen on a definition that never meets the CareShield test.

Is it free?

Yes. The calculators and guides are free. A result appears in your browser before anyone asks for a phone number. Sending the form, if you want quotes for those figures, does not add a fee on this website.

Will you call me?

Not because you opened a page. We contact you only if you send the form or message us. You can read every result with the form left blank.

How does this site work?

The page does the arithmetic in your browser from the rules and the numbers you type. If you ask for quotes, we use your name, number and those figures only to reply about that enquiry. We do not sell the list. Personal data is handled under Singapore's Personal Data Protection Act. We are not an insurer and this is not financial advice.

Get a personalised breakdown

The calculator above runs in the browser with no phone number. Leave your details only if you want quotes or an audit for the same figures.

Fiona Wang (Wang Ye), PropNex Realty Pte. Ltd.. CEA Reg. No. R068552B. Agency licence L3008022J.

We'll reply on WhatsApp. Your details go only to our agent and are never sold. See our privacy notice.

Sources

Facts on this page were checked against these sources on 30 October 2026.

  1. MoneySense: Understanding disability income insurance, updated 28 September 2026 moneysense.gov.sg, checked 30 October 2026
  2. MoneySense: Understanding health insurance (how the products differ) moneysense.gov.sg, checked 30 October 2026
  3. MoneySense: Understanding hospital cash insurance moneysense.gov.sg, checked 30 October 2026
  4. MoneySense: Assessing your insurance needs moneysense.gov.sg, checked 30 October 2026

Fact-checked against HDB, IRAS, CPF, MAS.

See the numbersSend me quotes for these figures