On this page
- The short answer
- What each one is built to do
- The interest you give up if CPF pays for the ILP
- Income now, income later, and a lump sum
- How to compare without a fake rate of return
- Checklist
- A review that keeps the two products apart
- What “risk-free interest” is doing in this comparison
- Keep the printouts dated
Key takeaways
- CPF LIFE is lifelong retirement income. An ILP is units plus insurance.
- CPF says investments can lose money, and CPF interest is the alternative it names.
- Higher-risk ILPs are not in the CPF Investment Scheme.
- Illustrated ILP rates are scenarios. CPF LIFE payouts follow CPF's own rules.
The numbers
- CPF LIFE
- Retirement income for life, under CPF rules
- ILP
- Units you can lose, plus a death benefit formula
- If you do not want market risk
- CPF says leave savings in CPF accounts
- CPFIS ILPs
- Allowed only if included. Higher-risk ILPs are out
- Endorsement
- CPF Board does not endorse CPFIS products
The short answer
“ILP vs CPF LIFE” sounds like a returns contest. It is a category error unless you first say what you want at 65. CPF LIFE is how CPF turns retirement savings into an income for as long as you live. An ILP is a life insurance policy that buys units. MoneySense puts an annuity in the retirement-income sentence and an ILP in the units-and-charges sentence. CPF Board, on the CPFIS page, tells members that investments can lose money and that leaving savings in CPF earns risk-free interest if they are not confident of investing.
You can hold both. You can also spend CPF savings on an ILP that is included under CPFIS and then have less in CPF LIFE. That trade is the real decision. The ILP hub explains units. The CPF LIFE pages explain the annuity. This page keeps them from being treated as substitutes.
What each one is built to do
| Question | CPF LIFE | Investment-linked policy |
|---|---|---|
| Main job | Retirement income under CPF’s scheme | Life cover plus an investment in sub-funds you pick |
| What you can lose | CPF publishes the rules for the plan you are on. This page does not restate payout formulas | MoneySense: you can lose the entire investment. Usually no guaranteed cash value |
| Who invests | CPF, under the LIFE scheme | You, by choosing sub-funds. The insurer does not set the strategy the way it does for whole life |
| Monthly income | The point of the scheme | Not the point, unless a specific contract adds an income feature you have read |
| Death benefit | CPF’s own rules for what remains | The formula in the policy: higher of sum assured or units, or some combination |
| Charges | Not an ILP charge table | Insurance charge, fund fee, administration, possible spread and surrender charge |
| Endorsement | It is the national scheme | CPF does not endorse CPFIS ILPs. MoneySense does not recommend a brand |
MoneySense’s annuity sentence is worth keeping beside any ILP that is sold as retirement income. An annuity provides a retirement income as it guarantees fixed payments at monthly intervals, for as long as the policyholder lives, or for a fixed period. An ILP illustration does not become that sentence because the highest column looks smooth. Illustrated rates are scenarios before fund management charges, and they are not limits on what the fund will do. The illustration guide is why the column is not a payout.
The interest you give up if CPF pays for the ILP
CPFIS is optional. CPF’s product list, updated September 2025, includes investment-linked insurance products for OA and for SA, and it says higher-risk ILPs are not included. The same page’s important note says the Board does not specifically endorse any provider or product included under CPFIS. All investments come with risk. You may lose all or a portion of the amount invested. If you are not confident of investing on your own, you may consider leaving your money in your CPF accounts, which earns risk-free interest.
That note is the comparison, stated by CPF rather than by an insurer. The dollars you move into an ILP stop earning the OA or SA interest CPF would have credited, and they start earning whatever the sub-fund earns after ILP charges, which can be negative. The quarterly interest rates are published by CPF. Type them from CPF’s page on the day you decide. A guide that freezes “the OA rate” goes stale, so this one does not freeze it.
MoneySense adds the ILP side of the same trade. There are no guaranteed returns. Insurance charges are paid from the investment and rise with age. Units may not be enough to pay them. For CPFIS sub-funds, the risk classification is only a very broad guide to whether the fund suits you. It is not a forecast, and it is not a promise that a lower-risk class will beat OA interest.
The mechanics of which plans you may buy, the self-awareness steps, and SRS as a separate pot are on the CPF or SRS page. Do not use this page as a shopping list of funds. Fund names on CPF’s classification chart change, and some are marked closed to new CPF money.
Income now, income later, and a lump sum
People who search “ILP income vs CPF annuity” are often looking at a brochure that shows coupons or withdrawals. A partial withdrawal from an ILP is a sale of units. It can incur a surrender charge, and it can leave too few units to pay the insurance charge. It ends when the units end. CPF LIFE’s purpose is an income that continues for life under the plan’s rules, not until a fund is depleted. Those are different promises. If you want the annuity comparison against a private insurer’s annuity, use the annuity page. If the brochure is an ILP with a withdrawal, use the withdrawal page and do not call the withdrawal a LIFE payout.
A single premium ILP bought at 55 with OA savings is also a bet about the years before and after CPF LIFE starts. Once the money is in the ILP, getting it back into CPF is not a button this page can promise. Check with CPF and the insurer about selling the units and the consequences for your retirement account. We did not verify a universal “put it back” rule, so we will not describe one. Assume the move is one way until both CPF and the insurer say otherwise in writing.
Leaving a bequest is the other job people mix in. An ILP death benefit may pay units or a sum to a nominee. CPF LIFE’s treatment of savings if you die is CPF’s publication, and it depends on the plan and on whether payouts have started. Read CPF’s current LIFE booklet for that, and the policy for the ILP. The nomination guide only covers the insurance contract. It does not nominate CPF savings.
How to compare without a fake rate of return
Do not pick a fund’s best historical year and set it next to a CPF LIFE payout estimate. MoneySense says past performance is not a guide to the future. Do this instead.
Write the retirement income you need in today’s dollars, from your own budget, not from a chart. See what CPF’s planner currently estimates for the LIFE plan you are on or could be on, using CPF’s tool and CPF’s assumptions. That estimate is CPF’s, and it changes when CPF updates the parameters. Note it with the date you printed it.
Then look at the ILP only for the job it actually does. If it is a CPFIS single premium with a thin death benefit, it is an investment of CPF money, and the question is whether you accept the chance of loss in exchange for a chance of a higher outcome than CPF interest. If it is a protection ILP paid with cash, it is not competing with CPF LIFE at all. It is competing with term insurance and with whatever you would invest beside it. The term comparison is that contest.
Put the ILP charges on the table: allocation, insurance charge, fund fee, any spread, surrender charge. A comparison that ignores them will prefer the ILP for a reason the documents do not support. The 0% column, if you have an illustration, shows the policy with no fund growth. CPF interest is not 0%. An ILP scenario at 0% losing to CPF interest is the point of that column.
Checklist
- Name the job: lifelong income, a lump-sum investment, or a death benefit.
- Print the CPF planner output and the date. Do not rely on a memory of a payout.
- If the ILP would be paid from OA or SA, confirm the plan is on the current CPFIS list and is not a higher-risk ILP.
- Read CPF's sentence that the Board does not endorse the product and that you can lose the amount invested.
- Read MoneySense's sentence that ILP returns are not guaranteed.
- Keep CPF LIFE as the income plan unless you have deliberately chosen a different income contract and read its guarantees.
- Do not treat an ILP withdrawal schedule as an annuity.
- Do not move OA or SA because a sub-fund beat CPF interest in a past chart.
A review that keeps the two products apart
Choose Investment-linked policy (ILP) and Free ILP policy review if the contract in your hand is an ILP, and say in the notes if the alternative is leaving the money in CPF. Attach the CPFIS status of the plan if you know it, and the latest statement. We will not project a LIFE payout and an ILP fund on one graph. We will line up the guarantee, the charge, and the income each document actually offers.
What “risk-free interest” is doing in this comparison
CPF’s phrase is doing a specific job. It is the alternative to investing, stated by the same Board that runs CPFIS. It is not a claim that every CPF dollar is a bank deposit covered by the deposit insurance scheme, and it is not a number you should memorise from a blog, because OA and SA rates are published for a quarter and include floors and extra interest rules that CPF’s own page explains. When you compare an ILP, the fair use of the phrase is: the dollars you move out stop receiving whatever CPF would have credited, and they take MoneySense’s investment risk instead, including the chance of losing the amount invested.
That is a lower bar than “will the fund beat CPF”. You do not need the fund to beat CPF for the move to be allowed. You need to accept that it might not, and that charges make the hurdle higher than the gross fund return. Insurance charges, a spread, and a surrender charge are hurdles CPF interest does not have. A CPFIS expense-ratio cap, if the current booklet still states one for the risk class, is a cap on the fund fee for admission to the scheme. It is not a cap on the insurance charge of the policy. Read both. We are not printing a cap percentage from an older booklet as if it were this quarter’s rule. Open CPF’s current criteria if you want the figure.
CPF LIFE then sits on top of whatever savings remain. A smaller OA or SA because you invested, or because the investment lost money, feeds into a smaller LIFE payout under CPF’s formulas. The planner is how you see a version of that, with CPF’s assumptions, on the day you run it. Re-run it after any large move. Do not subtract a fund’s hoped-for gain inside the planner. The planner is not an ILP calculator. The illustration guide is not a LIFE calculator. Keeping them apart is the whole point of the four-line sheet.
If you are already in LIFE and payouts have started, the question changes again. Investing through CPFIS is generally a pre-retirement decision about savings, and CPF’s rules on what you can still invest after payouts start are CPF’s to state. Check the current page. Do not assume an ILP top-up from OA is available in the year a LIFE payout is also being paid. The top-up page is the insurance mechanic. CPF’s eligibility is the prior gate.
Keep the printouts dated
A CPF planner screenshot without a date is how an old estimate becomes a promise in a later argument. Write the date on the LIFE figure, the date on the interest rate, and the date on the ILP statement. Once a year is enough. If nothing changed, the sheet stays. If CPF revises parameters or the ILP statement shows a charge you did not expect, rebuild the four lines. The comparison is a habit of documents, not a one-time blog conclusion. File it with the policy, not in a chat thread.
Send me quotes for these figures
What you need before a quote
- The product summary charge table and the latest statement
- Account value, the unit price date, and any surrender charge
- Whether you still need the death benefit, a critical illness rider, or other cover
- A replacement term quote, if you would buy cover again
- Fund factsheets for the sub-funds you actually hold
Other ways to compare in Singapore
- compareFIRST, the life-insurance shelf MoneySense points to. Direct Purchase plans there are commission-free up to the published cap.
- The insurer's own site, if you already know the product and want its illustration.
- A licensed insurance broker you choose. We do not name one and we do not publish a phone number for one.
- A bank that distributes the policy, if that is where you bank. Ask them what they are paid. We do not list a rate.
- The calculators on this site, which show a result before you send a form.
Questions on this topic
Can an ILP pay me a salary in retirement the way CPF LIFE does?
Only if you sell units yourself, or if a specific contract has an income feature you have read. MoneySense describes an annuity, not an ILP, as the product that pays a retirement income at intervals for life or for a fixed period. CPF LIFE is that annuity inside CPF. An ILP account value is not a monthly salary.
Should I move OA or SA into an ILP to beat CPF interest?
CPF says all investments carry risk and you may lose what you invest. It also says that if you are not confident, leave the money in CPF to earn risk-free interest. The current OA and SA rates are on CPF's site for the quarter. We are not going to type a rate here that the next quarter can change. An ILP has no guaranteed return, in MoneySense's words.
Is a CPFIS ILP approved, so it is safe?
Inclusion is not approval of the outcome. CPF says it does not endorse providers or products under CPFIS. Higher-risk ILPs are excluded. The risk class is a broad guide only.
What about a private annuity instead?
That comparison is on the [CPF LIFE versus private annuity page](/cpf-life-vs-annuity/). A private annuity is not an ILP. Do not use an ILP illustration's highest column as if it were an annuity quote.
Does the ILP death benefit replace CPF LIFE for my family?
They pay different people under different rules. CPF LIFE has its own payout and bequest structure, published by CPF. An ILP pays the death benefit in the insurance contract, which may be the units, a sum assured, or a combination. Read both. Neither cancels the other by default.
Is it free?
Yes. The calculators and guides are free. A result appears in your browser before anyone asks for a phone number. Sending the form, if you want quotes for those figures, does not add a fee on this website.
Will you call me?
Not because you opened a page. We contact you only if you send the form or message us. You can read every result with the form left blank.
How does this site work?
The page does the arithmetic in your browser from the rules and the numbers you type. If you ask for quotes, we use your name, number and those figures only to reply about that enquiry. We do not sell the list. Personal data is handled under Singapore's Personal Data Protection Act. We are not an insurer and this is not financial advice.
Get a personalised breakdown
The calculator above runs in the browser with no phone number. Leave your details only if you want quotes or an audit for the same figures.
Sources
Facts on this page were checked against these sources on 8 November 2026.
- CPF Board: CPF Investment Scheme options cpf.gov.sg, checked 8 November 2026
- CPF Board: investment products included under CPFIS (updated September 2025) cpf.gov.sg, checked 8 November 2026
- MoneySense: Understanding ILPs, updated 28 September 2026 moneysense.gov.sg, checked 8 November 2026
- MoneySense: Comparing term and bundled products, updated 28 September 2026 moneysense.gov.sg, checked 8 November 2026
Fact-checked against HDB, IRAS, CPF, MAS.

