On this page
- The short answer
- What to put side by side
- 1. Use the protector scale before you pay to keep 50%
- 2. A new insurer does not inherit the protected 50%
- 3. Windscreen cover is glass, and the excess is still a schedule line
- 4. A courtesy car is a set of days and a class of car, not a promise of your own model
- 5. Any-workshop cover is a choice of repairer, priced as an extra
- 6. Occupant personal accident pays a sum for injury, and it is not hospital insurance
- 7. Key replacement is the key, the lock, or both, and only if the clause lists them
- 8. Excess waiver removes an excess you should already have read
- A pass through the document
- What this list will not do
- This week
- What to send with the form
Key takeaways
- With the same insurer, a protector keeps 50% after one claim, leaves 20% after two, and nil after three or more.
- Move insurer after a claim and GIA's example leaves 20% after one claim, and nil after two or more.
- Protected NCD may not transfer. The worth-it page compares the protector premium with the discount you would lose.
- Windscreen, courtesy car, any-workshop, occupant cover, keys, and excess waiver are each priced on the quote.
The numbers
- Same insurer, one claim
- Protector keeps 50%
- Same insurer, two claims
- 20% left
- New insurer, one claim
- 20% left
- Price of each add-on
- On the quote
The short answer
A car insurance add-on is worth questioning when you can say which claim it changes and what it costs on your quote. The one scale that is published is the NCD protector for a private car. Stay with the same insurer and one claim keeps 50%, two claims leave 20%, and three or more leave nil. Take the next policy to a new insurer and one claim leaves 20%, while two or more leave nil. Protected NCD may not transfer. Every other extra on this list, from windscreen to excess waiver, has a price only your insurer can print.
The protector guide states the scale. The worth-it page is the comparison of that premium with the discount a claim would remove. Neither page is a ranking of insurers.
What to put side by side
| Add-on | What it changes | What it does not do | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| NCD protector, same insurer | One claim keeps 50%, two leave 20%, three or more leave nil | It does not freeze the base premium | On the quote |
| NCD protector, then a new insurer | One claim leaves 20%, two or more leave nil | Protected NCD may not transfer | On the quote |
| Windscreen | Glass, on the wording | It is not own-damage cover for the whole car | On the quote |
| Courtesy car | A car while yours is repaired, if the wording says so | It is not a hire car of your choosing for as long as you like | On the quote |
| Any workshop | Where the repair may be done | It is not a discount you can assume | On the quote |
| Occupant personal accident | A sum on injury in the car, if the schedule says so | It is not MediShield Life | On the quote |
| Key replacement | Keys, if the clause includes them | It is not cover for a stolen car | On the quote |
| Excess waiver | The excess you would have paid, on its terms | It is not a promise of a zero-cost claim | On the quote |
Hold the underlying cover still. An add-on on a third-party policy does not recreate comprehensive own damage. Read the excess guide before you pay to waive a figure you have not circled.
1. Use the protector scale before you pay to keep 50%
The protector is an optional extra on top of the discount you have already earned. Without it, one private-car claim takes 50% to 20%, 40% to 10%, and 30% or under to zero. With it, and only if you renew with the same insurer, one claim keeps 50%, two claims leave 20%, and three or more leave nil. The benefit is that softer step, not a ban on claims and not a cap on the repair bill. GIA describes the protector in the private-car example. Do not assume a motorcycle or a commercial vehicle follows the same protected table. Those vehicles already fall to zero after one claim on the common scale.
The worth-it page tells you to set the protector premium beside the extra you would pay if one claim cut 50% to 20% and you climbed back. If you already know you will leave the insurer after a claim, that page’s reading of GIA is that the protector does not change the single-claim outcome at the new insurer. Pay for the path you will actually take.
2. A new insurer does not inherit the protected 50%
The second line of the same GIA example is the one people skip. Move the policy and one claim leaves 20%. Two or more leave nil. Protected NCD may not transfer. Buying the protector and then shopping purely on price after a bump can mean you paid for a benefit the next insurer will not show. Ask, in writing, whether a protected percentage is recognised, and at what figure, before you treat the add-on as portable.
Write two renewals on paper: stay, and leave. The stay column uses 50% after one claim. The leave column uses 20%. The premium difference between those columns is the insurer’s arithmetic on its base, which you must ask for. This page will not supply a sample premium. The protector guide keeps the percentages in one place so the quote has something to be checked against.
3. Windscreen cover is glass, and the excess is still a schedule line
A windscreen add-on pays for glass on the terms printed next to it. It does not repair the rest of the car, and it does not automatically leave your no-claim discount untouched. Whether a glass claim counts as a claim for NCD is a sentence in the wording. Read that sentence. Some policies fold glass into the main cover. Some sell it as an extra. The label on the brochure is weaker than the clause.
Any excess for the glass is a dollar amount on the schedule. There is no single national windscreen excess to quote here. If the glass costs less than the excess, the add-on does not pay. Ask for the excess and for whether a glass-only claim moves NCD, with and without the extra. Those two answers, plus the price of the extra, are the whole decision.
4. A courtesy car is a set of days and a class of car, not a promise of your own model
Courtesy car, sometimes called a replacement car, is transport while the insured car is in for a repair the policy has accepted. The clause states the number of days, the category of car, and whether a delay in parts stops the clock. None of those figures is published as a national rule. A premium that looks small can buy three days of a small car, which may not match a repair that waits on a panel. Ask for the day limit, who books the car, and what happens if the workshop the insurer named has no courtesy car that week.
If you already have another car in the household, the value of this extra is the days you would actually need a third vehicle. If you do not, the value is the hire cost you would pay yourself for the same days. The hire cost is a quote from a hire firm. It is not a figure this page should invent.
5. Any-workshop cover is a choice of repairer, priced as an extra
The main policy may already send you to an authorised workshop. Any-workshop, or “own workshop”, is the extra that lifts that restriction, in whole or in part. The partial version matters. Some wordings allow your workshop only if the insurer has approved the estimate first. Some charge a higher excess when you choose. The higher excess is on the schedule. Do not describe the extra as “repairs anywhere” until the clause says that.
Put the workshop rule and this add-on on the same line of the quote. Paying for any-workshop on a policy that already allowed your workshop is a duplicate. Refusing the extra on a policy that will not pay your workshop is a choice to accept the panel. Either choice is coherent. The incoherent one is assuming the cheaper premium still lets you book the workshop you used last time.
6. Occupant personal accident pays a sum for injury, and it is not hospital insurance
An occupant personal accident add-on pays a stated sum if someone in the car dies or is disabled in the way the clause defines. It is accident cover tied to the vehicle. It is not MediShield Life, not an Integrated Shield plan, and not a substitute for the medical bills section you may think you already hold on a life policy. The sum per seat, the seats it includes, and whether the driver is inside the definition are on the schedule. A policy can cover passengers and leave the driver to a separate personal accident plan, or the reverse.
Ask who is an occupant, whether a named driver who is injured is included, and whether the benefit is reduced when a seat belt was not worn if the clause says so. If the clause is silent, do not fill the silence with a rule from another product. The price of the extra is on the quote. Compare that price with the personal accident cover the household already pays for, so you do not buy the same accident twice without meaning to.
7. Key replacement is the key, the lock, or both, and only if the clause lists them
Losing a key is a different event from crashing the car. A key add-on pays to replace keys, and sometimes to replace locks or recode a transponder, up to a limit the schedule states. A stolen car is an own-damage or theft claim on the main policy, if you bought that cover. Do not expect the key extra to pay for the car because the thief used the key. Do not expect the main theft cover to pay for a lost key that did not result in a theft, unless the wording says keys are included.
Ask whether one key or the full set is covered, whether a bag stolen with the keys is a separate claim, and what evidence the insurer wants. The limit in dollars is check with your insurer. If the only key you worry about is a building access card, this vehicle add-on is the wrong contract.
8. Excess waiver removes an excess you should already have read
Excess waiver, or excess protector, pays some or all of the excess you would otherwise pay on a claim. It does not raise the amount the insurer pays the workshop above the loss, and it does not stop NCD from moving unless the protector in section 1 is a separate extra you also bought. The excess guide is the page for the excess itself. Waiver is only meaningful after you know which excess applies: own damage, a young driver, an unnamed driver, windscreen, or a workshop choice. Waiving an excess that was never going to apply to your claim is a premium for a zero.
Ask which excesses the waiver touches, whether it applies once a year or once a claim, and the premium. Add that premium to the protector, the glass, the courtesy car, the workshop choice, the occupant benefit, and the keys. The stack is the true price of the “fully loaded” quote. There is no correct stack for every driver. There is a stack you can explain, line by line, on your own schedule.
A pass through the document
Open the quote and list every optional extra by name, premium, and the one claim it changes. Next to the protector, write “same insurer: 50, then 20, then nil” and “new insurer: 20, then nil”. If the quote does not say which of those paths you are buying, ask before you pay. Circle any excess the waiver claims to remove, and confirm that excess exists on the schedule. A blank price next to a ticked box is not a free benefit. It is a line the insurer still has to fill.
What this list will not do
It will not name a best insurer, a cheapest premium, or a score out of ten. A price belongs on your schedule, on compareFIRST where that tool lists the product, or on the insurer’s quote for the profile you enter. A blog table that freezes last quarter’s quote is already stale.
It will not turn a forum post into a fact. Threads are where these questions show up. They are not a source for a sum assured, a yield, a waiting period, or a claim ratio. No reader is named here.
It will not replace the NCD protector guide. If a point here is only a pointer, follow the link and read the source named on that page.
This week
- The job of this policy is one sentence, written down.
- The clause for each heading above is circled on your own document.
- Any missing figure is written as "check with your insurer", not guessed.
- Cover you already hold is listed once, including CPF schemes and employer cover.
- Do not treat a guide multiple, or another person's premium, as your price.
- Do not buy from a ranking table on this site. We do not publish one.
What to send with the form
The form at the bottom of this page is the insurance enquiry. Choose the cover that matches this guide and say which heading you are stuck on. WhatsApp, from the button on the site, is the same request. There is no fee on this website for reading the page or for sending the form.
Send the quote page that lists each add-on and its premium, and say whether you expect to renew with the same insurer after a claim. The protector answer depends on that choice.
Nothing here is financial advice. We are not an insurer. Do not attach a photograph of someone else’s policy and expect their number to be yours. Do attach the page of your own summary that contains the clause.
Send me quotes for these figures
What you need before a quote
- Your no-claim discount and the renewal premium
- The protector add-on from the invite, if you are pricing one
- COE date and outstanding loan, if you are testing a total loss
Other ways to compare in Singapore
- compareFIRST, the life-insurance shelf MoneySense points to. Direct Purchase plans there are commission-free up to the published cap.
- The insurer's own site, if you already know the product and want its illustration.
- A licensed insurance broker you choose. We do not name one and we do not publish a phone number for one.
- A bank that distributes the policy, if that is where you bank. Ask them what they are paid. We do not list a rate.
- The calculators on this site, which show a result before you send a form.
Questions on this topic
Does the protector travel if I switch insurer?
Protected NCD may not transfer. GIA's scale for a new insurer is harsher: one claim leaves 20%, and two or more leave nil. Read the worth-it note before you pay for a benefit you plan to leave behind.
Is the protector price published?
No national price is in the GIA scale. The premium for the protector is on your quote. Compare it with the extra you would pay if one claim cut 50% to 20% and you stayed to climb back.
Does windscreen cover have one excess?
No. An excess for glass, if any, is on the schedule. Do not borrow another product's windscreen excess. The excess guide says where that figure lives.
Should I buy every add-on?
No. Each extra pays a narrow event. Add the prices on your own quote. If the stack costs more than the loss you are willing to pay yourself, leave the ones you can fund alone.
Is it free?
Yes. The calculators and guides are free. A result appears in your browser before anyone asks for a phone number. Sending the form, if you want quotes for those figures, does not add a fee on this website.
Will you call me?
Not because you opened a page. We contact you only if you send the form or message us. You can read every result with the form left blank.
How does this site work?
The page does the arithmetic in your browser from the rules and the numbers you type. If you ask for quotes, we use your name, number and those figures only to reply about that enquiry. We do not sell the list. Personal data is handled under Singapore's Personal Data Protection Act. We are not an insurer and this is not financial advice.
Get a personalised breakdown
The calculator above runs in the browser with no phone number. Leave your details only if you want quotes or an audit for the same figures.
Sources
Facts on this page were checked against these sources on 12 November 2026.
- GIA: No Claims Discount gia.org.sg, checked 12 November 2026
Fact-checked against HDB, IRAS, CPF, MAS.
