On this page
- The short answer
- What you are comparing
- Fees, without borrowing a blog’s percentage
- Projections that do not belong on one chart
- Leaving the ILP for the platform
- Checklist
- A review of the two documents
- Behaviour, which is the part neither product can sign for you
- If you stay, use the robo idea inside the policy only where it belongs
Key takeaways
- The robo portfolio is not a death benefit. The ILP contract is.
- Compare charges from both documents, not from a forum.
- Illustrated ILP rates are not a robo's projected return.
- Surrendering the ILP ends the cover. Price term if you still need it.
The numbers
- ILP
- Life cover plus units, with policy charges
- Robo
- A portfolio. No insurance charge inside it
- If you do not need cover
- MoneySense points to unit trusts and ETFs
- Fees
- Read each provider. We do not print a platform's fee
- Risk
- You can lose money in either investment
The short answer
An ILP and a robo-adviser both end up holding investments. Only one of them is a life insurance policy. MoneySense describes the ILP as premiums that buy units, some of which are sold for insurance and other charges, with you bearing the risk and with no guaranteed returns. It says that if you do not need the insurance, you may consider unit trusts and exchange traded funds, and that the sub-fund you want may be available without the policy. A robo-adviser is one way people in Singapore hold those funds. It is not a product MoneySense defines on the ILP page, so this guide will not pretend there is an official “robo versus ILP” table. The comparison is the one you build from two documents: the ILP product summary, and the platform’s current fee and risk disclosure.
People search “ILP vs robo advisor” and then the names of platforms. r/singaporefi threads often ask whether to surrender and invest the premium elsewhere. The arithmetic is personal. The categories are not. The ILP hub is the policy. The buy term and invest the rest page is the behaviour of actually investing the gap. This page stops the two products being scored as if they were the same shape.
What you are comparing
| Question | ILP | Robo-adviser portfolio |
|---|---|---|
| Contract | A life policy | An investment account, on that platform’s terms |
| Death benefit | A formula in the policy: sum assured, unit value, or a combination | Whatever the portfolio is worth. No chosen sum assured |
| Insurance charge | Rises with age, paid by selling units | None inside the portfolio. You buy term separately if you need cover |
| Fund fee | On the sub-fund factsheet | On the funds the platform uses, plus the platform’s own fee. Read both |
| Early exit | Surrender charge possible on a partial or full sale | The platform’s own exit rules. Not an insurer surrender scale |
| Illustration | LIA’s 0%, B% and C% scenarios, when an illustration is required | The platform’s projection, if it offers one. A different method |
| Who chooses funds | You, from the insurer’s menu, or a mix you set | You, or a portfolio the platform builds from your answers |
| “Forced saving” | A regular premium debit, until you holiday, reduce or surrender | A standing instruction you can usually stop. Confirm on the app |
The row people skip is the death benefit. A robo that costs less to hold is not a bargain if the ILP was also the family’s only cover and you cancel it. Price term for the sum you still need. If the ILP sum assured was only a thin 101-style benefit, the 101 page explains why the insurance you would be giving up may be small, and why that still does not make the surrender value equal to premiums paid.
Fees, without borrowing a blog’s percentage
MoneySense lists ILP charges you can go and find: insurance coverage charges that depend on cover, age, gender and smoking; fund management fees; policy administration charges; surrender charges on an early partial or full sale; a premium allocation rate; a bid-offer spread usually around 5%; and a switching fee after a free allowance. Fees may change. Distribution costs, including commissions, are typically taken from the sale of units. LIA says the total distribution cost shown on the illustration is not an extra bill. It is already in the premium.
A robo-adviser publishes a platform fee, and the funds inside the portfolio publish theirs. Some platforms say they use cash or SRS, some say they can hold CPFIS products. None of those sentences is a number this page will copy, because the honest figure is the one on the page the day you open the account. Print it. Print the ILP summary the same week. A comparison made from a 2023 forum post and a 2026 campaign is not a comparison.
What you can say without those numbers is structural. The ILP insurance charge has no twin in the robo account. If you add a term premium beside the robo so that the family stays protected, the term premium is part of the comparison. The term and whole life calculator compounds a gap you type. It does not know a platform’s fee and it does not cancel ILP units. Type only figures you have read.
Allocation is the other structural point. A regular premium ILP may invest only a slice of the early premiums. A robo instruction typically invests the amount you send, minus the fees the platform discloses. MoneySense’s teaching example, $200 of $1,000 at a 20% allocation rate, is how to read a low allocation. It is not your rate. A back-end ILP invests 100% and charges you for leaving early. MoneySense says the overall effect is similar to front-end loading. A robo account does not use that pair of structures. Its exit cost, if any, is its own.
Projections that do not belong on one chart
The ILP illustration, when you get one, uses rates before fund management charges and warns that they are not limits. A single premium plan does not even get the illustration unless the death or critical illness benefit exceeds 150% of the relevant premiums. A robo projection, if the platform shows one, is built on the platform’s assumptions. Putting the ILP’s highest illustrated rate next to a robo’s “expected return” double-counts optimism and mixes two methods. Prefer the ILP’s 0% column, which shows charges with no growth, and the platform’s fee in percent, which you can read without a forecast.
MoneySense says not to rely on past returns. A chart where a sub-fund or a model portfolio won last year is not the test. The test is whether you will still hold the investment when it falls, and whether the ILP’s insurance charge will force sales of units at the same time. That forced sale has no equivalent in a portfolio that does not pay an insurance charge. It is the mechanical reason a bad market hurts a high-cover ILP harder than it hurts the same fund held alone. If your ILP is a thin investment-oriented plan, the charge is smaller and this point is smaller. Read the charge. Do not assume you are in the dramatic case.
Leaving the ILP for the platform
The sequence that does not skip a step:
Confirm the surrender value in writing, or from a current quote, including the surrender charge for this policy year. Unit prices move until the sale is priced at the next valuation. The surrender guide is the form. The calculator only repeats what you type.
Confirm what cover ends. Riders end with the policy unless the contract says otherwise. If you still need a sum assured, apply for term and wait until it is in force before you surrender, if your health makes a decline possible. Check with the insurer you would buy from. We cannot see an underwriting result.
Confirm the platform will accept the money. Cash is straightforward. CPF and SRS are not a free transfer into any app. Use the provider’s eligibility rules and the CPF LIFE comparison if the alternative is simply to leave CPF money where it is.
Confirm you will actually send the future premiums to the platform. The failure mode of “buy term and invest the rest” is spending the rest. A standing instruction is the practical version. An ILP debit was forced. A robo debit is only forced if you keep it turned on.
Inside the free-look, you do not need this sequence. Cancel the ILP in writing. The free-look page describes the investment-linked refund at market value.
Checklist
- Write whether you need the death benefit. If yes, get a term quote before any surrender.
- Print the ILP charge table and the platform's current fee page in the same week.
- Do not put an illustrated ILP rate and a platform projection on one chart.
- Ask whether the ILP sub-fund exists as a unit trust the platform can hold.
- Get the surrender charge for this year from the insurer, not from a thread.
- If CPF or SRS is involved, confirm both the exit and the new account are allowed.
- Do not assume a lower platform fee means a better outcome after you have dropped cover you needed.
- Do not quote a fee from memory. The page can change.
A review of the two documents
Choose Investment-linked policy (ILP) and Free ILP policy review. Say which platform you are looking at and paste its fee line, plus the ILP allocation line and insurance charge. We will not tell you to move. We will show which costs exist only on the policy, and whether the death benefit has been given a replacement in your plan.
Behaviour, which is the part neither product can sign for you
MoneySense’s buy-the-fund-directly suggestion assumes you will hold the fund. A robo account that you empty during a fall, or never fund after the ILP debit stops, is not the comparison the sheet describes. The ILP’s disadvantage, the charges, is also the feature people admit they used as a lock. If you need a lock, say so, and then decide whether the lock is worth the insurance charge and the surrender schedule. A standing instruction on a robo, or a monthly transfer you have actually kept for a year in a plain account, is evidence you might not need the lock. A promise to your future self is not evidence.
Write the last twelve months of non-ILP investing on the bottom of the sheet. If the line is empty, the exit column’s “I will invest the premium” is a hope. Keep the ILP until the line is a habit, or cut the sum assured so the ILP costs less while you build the habit, or accept a term policy and a cash balance that is not invested. Those are three honest options. Surrendering into a spending account and calling it a robo plan is a fourth, and it is the one the forums regret in a different costume.
The platform can also refuse you, or put you through a knowledge assessment if what it sells is an unlisted specified investment product. MoneySense says some ILPs may be specified investment products too. Passing one assessment and failing the other is a practical reason the move stalls. It is not a reason to invent a workaround. If the money is CPF or SRS, both the exit and the entry have to be allowed. A platform that advertises SRS is not automatically able to receive the surrender proceeds inside SRS. Timing and account names matter. Ask both institutions before you surrender, not after the cash has landed in a current account and lost the wrapper.
Revisit the sheet when either fee changes. Fees may not be guaranteed on the ILP, and platform fees move when the platform says they move. A decision made on old prints should be remade on new prints if you have not acted. The blank return row stays blank on every version.
If you stay, use the robo idea inside the policy only where it belongs
Staying does not mean ignoring the portfolio lesson. You can still simplify the sub-funds you hold, switch out of a narrow bet, and cut a sum assured that belongs in a term policy instead. Those are ILP tools. They are not a robo account, and they do not earn a platform’s fee schedule. Do them because the factsheets say the mix is wrong, not because a friend moved to an app. Review yearly, when the statement arrives, on the same day you glance at whatever you invest outside the policy. One review, two wrappers, no blended chart of returns. The blank row on the sheet stays blank whether you leave or stay. That is how the decision remains about costs and cover, which you can know, rather than about a race you cannot.
Send me quotes for these figures
What you need before a quote
- The product summary charge table and the latest statement
- Account value, the unit price date, and any surrender charge
- Whether you still need the death benefit, a critical illness rider, or other cover
- A replacement term quote, if you would buy cover again
- Fund factsheets for the sub-funds you actually hold
Other ways to compare in Singapore
- compareFIRST, the life-insurance shelf MoneySense points to. Direct Purchase plans there are commission-free up to the published cap.
- The insurer's own site, if you already know the product and want its illustration.
- A licensed insurance broker you choose. We do not name one and we do not publish a phone number for one.
- A bank that distributes the policy, if that is where you bank. Ask them what they are paid. We do not list a rate.
- The calculators on this site, which show a result before you send a form.
Questions on this topic
Is a robo-adviser safer than an ILP?
It is a different risk. The ILP adds insurance charges and a surrender schedule, and the units can still fall. A portfolio outside the policy has no insurance charge and no insurer surrender charge, and the investments can still fall. MoneySense says you bear ILP investment risk and can lose the entire investment. A robo does not remove market risk.
Should I name Endowus, Syfe or StashAway?
Those names appear in search next to ILP because people are comparing a policy with a platform they have seen advertised. This page does not review them and does not quote their fees, because fee schedules change and we did not lock a figure from each site on a single day. Open the platform's current fee page and the ILP product summary together.
Can the robo replace the death benefit?
No. If someone depends on the ILP sum assured, buy term or keep enough cover before you surrender. The [term comparison](/ilp-vs-term-insurance/) is that quote. A portfolio pays your estate whatever it is worth. It does not pay a chosen sum because you died.
Are the funds the same?
Sometimes the strategy is similar. MoneySense says the ILP sub-fund may also be offered as a unit trust. Share class, fee and wrapper still differ. The [sub-fund page](/how-to-read-ilp-sub-funds/) and the [ETF page](/ilp-vs-etf-and-unit-trust/) are the investment comparison. This page is the wrapper.
What about CPF or SRS?
Some platforms accept SRS or CPFIS products, and some ILPs do too. The rules are not the same product. Use the [CPF and SRS page](/cpf-or-srs-for-an-ilp/) and the provider's eligibility page. Do not move OA into a robo or an ILP because a chart beat CPF interest once.
Is it free?
Yes. The calculators and guides are free. A result appears in your browser before anyone asks for a phone number. Sending the form, if you want quotes for those figures, does not add a fee on this website.
Will you call me?
Not because you opened a page. We contact you only if you send the form or message us. You can read every result with the form left blank.
How does this site work?
The page does the arithmetic in your browser from the rules and the numbers you type. If you ask for quotes, we use your name, number and those figures only to reply about that enquiry. We do not sell the list. Personal data is handled under Singapore's Personal Data Protection Act. We are not an insurer and this is not financial advice.
Get a personalised breakdown
The calculator above runs in the browser with no phone number. Leave your details only if you want quotes or an audit for the same figures.
Sources
Facts on this page were checked against these sources on 8 November 2026.
- MoneySense: Understanding ILPs, updated 28 September 2026 moneysense.gov.sg, checked 8 November 2026
- MoneySense: ILP fees and pricing, updated 4 November 2026 moneysense.gov.sg, checked 8 November 2026
- MoneySense: Term and bundled products, updated 28 September 2026 moneysense.gov.sg, checked 8 November 2026
- LIA: ILP illustration format, updated 28 July 2026 lia.org.sg, checked 8 November 2026
Fact-checked against HDB, IRAS, CPF, MAS.
